For daily wit & wisdom, sign up for the 蜜桃恋人 newsletter.
No content available.
When summer arrives, so do the biting bugs! Can plants alone really repel mosquitoes and other nuisance insects in the garden? Here鈥檚 what the science says as well as a list of plants with actual insect-repellent properties.
Mosquitoes are more than a nuisance, as there are many mosquito-borne diseases out there, including viruses such as West Nile, Eastern Equine Encephalitis, and Dengue. It鈥檚 not just mosquitoes, either鈥攇nats, biting flies, ants, and other pests can take the fun right out of any outdoor activity.
Do Mosquito-Repellent Plants Really Work?
Mosquitoes and many other biting insects target their victims by the odors and gases we give off鈥攃arbon dioxide, sweat, and smelly feet, to name a few. Mosquitoes, for example, can be attracted by the carbon dioxide in our breath from as far as 150 feet away.
Luckily, the strong scents produced by some common garden plants can block the scent receptors that the bugs use to find us鈥攂ut simply including strongly scented plants in your garden isn鈥檛 enough to keep the bugs at bay. In most cases, a much stronger, more concentrated amount of a plant鈥檚 scent is needed to throw the bugs off your trail.
It鈥檚 All in the Oils
The key to generating a strong enough insect-repellent scent is to release the essential oils within a plant鈥檚 leaves. These oils actually have an insect-repelling effect. Burning sprigs of the plant or crushing the foliage are the best ways to release their oils.
At home, it鈥檚 easiest to crush the leaves and apply them topically whenever you鈥檙e working in the garden. Simply pinch off a few leaves and crush them in your hands to release their essential oils, then rub the crushed leaves on your skin to create a mosquito-repellent layer.
(WARNING: Be wary of allergies! Direct contact with the oils of some plants may irritate the skin. We recommend testing the crushed leaves on a small part of the underside of an arm or leg before applying it elsewhere.)
It鈥檚 important to keep in mind that although some plants may indeed repel insects, using them as suggested below will not produce the same insect-repelling results as commercial insect repellents, which have been engineered for effectiveness and longevity. In most cases, using the leaves from a plant will only provide moderate protection for a short period of time. As a rule of thumb, if you can鈥檛 smell the scent on yourself any longer, it鈥檚 probably not keeping the bugs away anymore!
Which Plants Have Insect-Repelling Properties?
Many plants that are labeled as 鈥渋nsect-repelling鈥 are, in fact, not. Specifically, the so-called 鈥渕osquito plant,鈥 Pelargonium citrosum, has shown little to no evidence of repelling mosquitoes despite its name and pleasantly lemon-scented leaves.
So, here are a few scented plants that actually have insect-repelling qualities when used correctly:
Lemon grass(Cymbopogon citratus) and citronella grass(C. nardus) have proven mosquito-repelling abilities thanks to the citronella oil contained within their leaves. The leaves can be crushed and rubbed on bare skin to ward off biting bugs. Tall, tropical grasses, lemon grass, and citronella grass will only survive as perennials in frost-free zones; those who live in colder climates will need to keep them in pots and bring them inside when temperatures drop in the fall.
Lemon thyme(Thymus citriodorus) is another citrus-scented plant that can be used as a topical insect repellent. Burning sprigs of lemon thyme (on the outdoor grill, for example) is also effective at keeping nuisance insects away from the immediate area.
Lemon balm(Melissa officinalis), like lemon thyme, gives off a scent that鈥檚 offensive to insects. Apply it topically. If you鈥檙e planning to grow it, keep in mind that lemon balm is in the mint family, so confine it to a pot to keep it from spreading like crazy!
Lavenderhas a strong scent that canrepel moths, flies, fleas, and mosquitoes. Use fresh or dry some of the flowers to hang around the house or put in with your clothing to keep bugs out. Here鈥檚 how to make lavender sachets.
Garlic keeps away more than vampires. To be effective against bugs, however, the cloves must be rubbed on the skin, which may end up being more offensive to other humans than to insects. (Sadly, consuming garlic hasn鈥檛 been shown to keep the bugs away.)
Rosemary may prevent flies and mosquitoes from ruining a cookout. If the bugs are really bad, throw a few sprigs of rosemary on the grill, and the aromatic smoke will help drive the mosquitoes away.
Basil(Ocimum basilicum)is a culinary herb that does double duty by repelling flies and mosquitoes, too. It鈥檚 one of the most pungent herbs and even gives off a strong scent without its leaves being crushed. If you鈥檙e looking for an insect-repelling plant that you can 鈥渟et and forget,鈥 basil is your best bet.
Catnip(Nepeta cataria) contains a substance called nepetalactone, which has been found to be even more effective than DEET at repelling mosquitoes in lab trials. Unfortunately, when crushed leaves were applied topically, catnip appeared to have little to no insect-repelling effect, so don鈥檛 depend on this plant to keep the mosquitoes away.
We鈥檙e sure other plants have acquired a bug-repelling reputation, but we wouldn鈥檛 depend on only a few plants to make our yards insect-free. One of the most effective things you can do to cut the mosquito population down is to eliminate any standing water where their larvae may be living.
American Beautyberry leaves also work very well. Stuff a quart jar with as many leaves as you can. Fill the jar with rubbing alcohol and let it soak for 5 days. Open the jar and throw away the leaves and pour the liquid into a spray bottle.
As for eating garlic...I think it's effectiveness all depends on the individual. Everyone's body chemistry is just a little bit different. Personally, I have found that regularly eating raw garlic cloves really does keep biting insects away from me, and I know one or two other people for whom it has the same effect. This is why it isn't backed by science: It doesn't work for everyone.
WHAT ABOUT THE CITRONELLA (GERANIUM TYPE) PLANT THAT IS SOLD IN LOTS OF NURSERIES ??? I ALWAYS BUY 2 AND PLACE ONE AT MY FRONT DOOR AND ONE AT MY BACKDOOR. IT IS RARE THAT A MOSQUITO EVEN ENTERS MY HOME !!!
The best repellent for all bugs, including those pesky gnats, is Palmer's Coconut Butter. Smear it on face, around ears, in your hair. Nothing will bother you. Reapply as needed. Of course, you'll have to shower afterwards, but nothing has ever worked as well as Palmer's.
Many years ago when I worked at a lakeside campground, I would rub fresh pennyroyal (a member of the mint family) on my exposed skin and never had any trouble with mosquitos.