Reader rating of 5 out of 5. 100% of readers would make this recipe again. Submit your own review!
This is a great recipe. My mother made this soup all the time when I was growing up. (She still makes it!) She would also add sliced hard boiled egg into the soup. If you like, you can also make it without the bacon, which is what I do and then add a spoon of butter. It's a nice comfort food. – Reviewed by Candi Fairburn
It was just wonderful. – Anonymous Review
When I came across this recipe it was in Recipes with a History and had the name Spook Soup. The family made this soup at Halloween time to have when the children came home from getting their Halloween treats and the rivals in the soup were called little ghost. I made this soup and was very pleased at the outcome. It is the best-tasting Potato Soup I have ever eaten. Will make this many times over my lifetime. – Reviewed by Dee Vernille
My grandmother was Pennsylvania Dutch and born in 1895. This recipe was exactly like the potato soup she made. If you use 1 cup evaporated milk and 1 cup water as a substitute for the milk, it makes the soup a little richer. I also use freshly ground black pepper - a little more than this recipe calls for. Try it ! – Anonymous Review
I've made this soup many times, and it's the best potato soup ever! My recipe was getting tattered from so much use, so I'm thrilled to find it online. – Reviewed by Cheryl Lewis
This is the same recipe my grandmother made for me as far back as I can remember and which she taught me. It can't be beat for flavor and being filling on a cold winter's day. Plus it lends well to you adding your own personal touches and changes. Make it once and you will have a family favorite. – Reviewed by Dennis James
My mom would make this on cold winter days to warm us up after a day outside. It's also a great comfort food! – Reviewed by Carollee Slodysko
We always had a fresh chopped onion to sprinkle on top along with a teaspoon of cider vinegar. The added crunch and tart taste was great. We had this nearly every day for lunch in the summer when I was growing up. This is a real comfort food. – Reviewed by Harvey Miller
Reader rating of 5 out of 5. 100% of readers would make this recipe again. Submit your own review!
This is a great recipe. My mother made this soup all the time when I was growing up. (She still makes it!) She would also add sliced hard boiled egg into the soup. If you like, you can also make it without the bacon, which is what I do and then add a spoon of butter. It's a nice comfort food. – Reviewed by Candi Fairburn
It was just wonderful. – Anonymous Review
When I came across this recipe it was in Recipes with a History and had the name Spook Soup. The family made this soup at Halloween time to have when the children came home from getting their Halloween treats and the rivals in the soup were called little ghost. I made this soup and was very pleased at the outcome. It is the best-tasting Potato Soup I have ever eaten. Will make this many times over my lifetime. – Reviewed by Dee Vernille
My grandmother was Pennsylvania Dutch and born in 1895. This recipe was exactly like the potato soup she made. If you use 1 cup evaporated milk and 1 cup water as a substitute for the milk, it makes the soup a little richer. I also use freshly ground black pepper - a little more than this recipe calls for. Try it ! – Anonymous Review
I've made this soup many times, and it's the best potato soup ever! My recipe was getting tattered from so much use, so I'm thrilled to find it online. – Reviewed by Cheryl Lewis
This is the same recipe my grandmother made for me as far back as I can remember and which she taught me. It can't be beat for flavor and being filling on a cold winter's day. Plus it lends well to you adding your own personal touches and changes. Make it once and you will have a family favorite. – Reviewed by Dennis James
My mom would make this on cold winter days to warm us up after a day outside. It's also a great comfort food! – Reviewed by Carollee Slodysko
We always had a fresh chopped onion to sprinkle on top along with a teaspoon of cider vinegar. The added crunch and tart taste was great. We had this nearly every day for lunch in the summer when I was growing up. This is a real comfort food. – Reviewed by Harvey Miller